Some great coherent surfaces, I will say, with immaculate balance between the cryptic and definition parts: “tail”…”tailless” and “slippery”…”slippery” being just two very blatant examples. I think my COD might be the simple but effective 8dn though. Nice job setter and more of this kind of chewy madness on a Friday I say you you, Mr Ed!
ACROSS
1 US historian’s description of Amundsen’s arrival at Pole? (8)
PRESCOTT – as in William H Prescott, the first American scientific historian, back in the 19th century. Amundsen’s was the first expedition to arrive at the South Pole in 1911, PRE-SCOTT by 34 days.
5 Agree to study remedy briefly (6)
CONCUR – CON [to study] + CUR{e} [remedy, abbreviated]. FOI
10 English town ultimately counted cost of untilled ground (6,9)
SUTTON COLDFIELD – ({counte}D COST OF UNTILLED*) [“ground”]. Biffable given a few crossers
11 Rich soil with, close by, stock all around (5,5)
BROWN EARTH – W NEAR [with | close by], BROTH [stock] all around that
13 Activator, oddly inactive for so long (4)
CIAO – {a}C{t}I{v}A{t}O{r}, with the odd letters deactivated
15 Rail, perhaps: one to put in shed (3,3)
HIT OUT – I TO “put in” HUT
17 Little drama in Wimbledon umpire’s words? (7)
PLAYLET – I understand a tennis umpire might shout things like PLAY! and LET!
18 Christian was one turning cheek, resolute (7)
PILGRIM – reversed LIP [cheek] + GRIM [resolute]. Christian being the eponym of Bunyan’s “Pilgrim’s Progress”
19 Dramatist needing writing instruments of old (6)
SHAWMS – SHAW needs MS. A shawm is a primitive oboe of some kind.
21 Pat of butter in large glass, just starting to turn (4)
GLIB – reversed B{utter} I{n} L{arge} G{lass}
22 Royal grant treated with disdain (10)
ARROGANTLY – (ROYAL GRANT*) [“treated”]. SOI
25 Feature from wartime film director Lee (8,7)
ANDERSON SHELTER – is ANDERSON Lindsay? Wes? Paul Thomas? Michael? Pick your favourite film director. The lee side is the one SHELTERed from the wind. Put them together to create a structure you might hide in during an air raid.
27 Sheriff, courtesy of grass, arresting old woman (6)
LAWMAN – LAWN [grass] “arresting” MA [old woman]
28 Old tracks supposedly set for broadcast by large Spanish lady (3,5)
LEY LINES – homophone of LAY [set] + L INES [large | Spanish lady]
DOWN
1 Disregard “X” placed under warrant (4,2)
PASS BY – BY [X, as in “times”], under PASS [warrant]
2 Scoff as leader eliminated from qualifier (3)
EAT – {h}EAT
3 Seek to take top off first in public building (5,5)
CROWN COURT – COURT is to seek [as in courting fame or disaster]; CROWN is to “top off” [as in crowning glory]. Arrange appropriately.
4 Hired parts necessary for automatic camera (5)
TICCA – hidden in {automa}TIC CA{mera}. Less “cleverly hidden” than “a word I’d never heard of”! But maybe some of your good selves have come across or even used it in the wild?
6 Tender, when speaking, for one for whom the earth moved? (4)
OFFA – homophone of OFFER, or you may vehemently disagree, along with my live-in Scot. Offa of Mercia is best remembered for building a big dyke to keep the Welsh in their place; I grew up on the Welsh side of it so can completely understand his point of view.
7 One’s advanced only so far (6,5)
CREDIT LIMIT – cryptic definition. The limit to which one can receive an advance or loan.
8 Art deco pieces entertaining camper (7)
REDCOAT – (ART DECO*). Hi-de-hi!
9 Odd creature with tail also includes a tailless variety (8)
PLATYPUS – PLUS [also] “includes” A TYP{e}. Sadly I basically biffed this in from “odd creature”.
12 Detonating on IOW left weird light in bay (5,6)
ORIEL WINDOW – (ON IOW L WEIRD*) [“detonated”]
14 Pile in to stop a slippery customer producing something slippery? (6,4)
BANANA PEEL – NAP [pile] in BAN A EEL [to stop | a | slippery customer]. Biffable from EEL.
16 What’s to come from retiring second time — gold chain (8)
TOMORROW – reversed MO T [second | time], plus OR ROW [gold | chain]
18 The twist in Animal Farm, perhaps, as told (7)
PIGTAIL – which sounds a lot like PIG TALE [Animal Farm, perhaps]
20 State syrup, heading off cough, has worked (6)
CYPRUS – (SYRUP C{ough}*), worked over
23 Boy having file removed from case of doctor (5)
OSSIE – {d}OSSIE{r}
24 A long number of answers, including right one (4)
ARIA – A A [(two) answers] “including” R I [right | one]
26 Style of cryptic down clue? (3)
TON – reverse cryptic, where TON is “not up”, ergo a cryptic clue for “down”.
Ticca was just given the Mephisto treatment, and there you go – finished.
15ac HIT OUT= RAIL which has usually been COOT;16dn I really must go to IKEA TOMORROW;
I did enter a dodgy TICCA at 4dn and BROWN EARTH at 11 ac – but the fun had gone out of it from a setter possibly determined to level the good Lord Verlaine, after his three minute wipe-out yesterday.
I would imagine our American friends might be stuck up at SUTTON COLDFIELD.
If one is a rich Brummie, yow lives in SUTTON COWL-FIELD: if yow’s filthy rich yow lives in SOWLIHULL- Lady Byron Lane – where all the ‘howses’ look like cinemas. My WOD.
FOI 2dn EAT
COD 8dn REDCOAT Hi-de-ho!
Clapton’s 28ac today’s earworm.
Edited at 2020-08-28 02:02 am (UTC)
Edited at 2020-08-28 03:07 am (UTC)
Edited at 2020-08-28 03:52 am (UTC)
DK PRESCOTT but the wordplay was helpful and it went in almost straightway. DK TICCA. DK OSSIE, which judging from the list of famous Ossies on Wiki seems to be mostly adopted by foreign sportsmen, none of them tennis players which might account for my never having heard of any of them.
Failed to parse CROWN COURT.
Edited at 2020-08-28 05:01 am (UTC)
And I suppose a “flip” is a sandal to Brits and such, as this sense is not found in Merriam-Webster.
I could only think of the homophonic OZZIE Obourne who wasn’t sporting.
William Hinkling Prescott d. 1859 wrote of Peru and Mexico.
Prescott, Arizona was named in his honour. Makes ‘No-No- Nanette’ seem plausibly modern!
I forgot to mention the old Anderson Shelter and what about Leroy Anderson. Remember him? Sleigh-ride etc!
I’ll take that on what was quite a toughy.
NHO ticca.
Thanks setter and V.
Hi-de-hi featured yellowcoats, it was Butlins that made REDCOATs famous. I did a summer in the kitchens at Pontins, aged eighteen, where they were bluecoats.
A BANANA skin is nowadays more figurative, but it is and always has been a skin.
PRESCOTT undoubtedly one of many contenders for COD, nho the historian.
I was a bit slow on the town, and I live there.
I have walked about half of the OFFA’s Dyke path, not my favourite.
I put in ANDERSON SHELTER and thought of James, Gerry and Sylvia, none of whom directed films as far as I know.
Thanks verlaine and setter, more of these please!
PRESCOTT from wordplay, since round here he’s a politician who punches above his weight, now sitting in The Other Place and ineligible for the Times.
OSSIE obviously Ardiles, no longer a boy even when he arrived at Spurs. The nearest I can get to the usual boy idea here, the diminutive, is that it’s short for Oscar, but not in my Chambers. Other suggestions are that its another form of Aussie and Liverpool for hospital.
TICCA only from hidden, never previously encountered and probably never to be seen again. Make mine chicken.
TON as the only sensible fit, being too blasted to spot the not up idea.
ANDERSON: I’ll take Lindsay, director of boundary pushing films such as If… and O Lucky Man. Or Jimmy (still alive, obviously) director of magic cricket balls whose magnificent 600th I heard while driving and nearly crashed the car with excitement, applause and pleasure.
BROWN EARTH not known as a particular thing, but apparently loads of it near me in Epping Forest. I’ll let my friends know.
Not all ARIAs are long, they only seem that way as the soprano goes for the second recapitulation.
Thanks V for elucidation where needed and obvious and infectious relish.
Thanks, Verlaine, for explaining 15ac, 25ac, 3d, 9d and 26d. I solved them but couldn’t parse them properly.
Joint COD to PRESCOTT and PIGTAIL.
COD: GLIB nicely disguised.
Yesterday’s answer: WWW has nine syllables, world wide web has three.
Today’s question: the TV series Crown Court and Billy the Fish in Viz are set in which fictional town?
…… perhaps is more appropriate?
LOI was SHAWMS, not a familiar word and I took too long to L&S writing instruments.
Thanks setter & V.
LOI was glib delayed by trying to get some reference to a goat before realising how simple the answer was.
Lots to enjoy here, pleased I got shawms though took a time to dredge the musical reference from the recesses of my memory. Great end to the week even if a disappointment to miss by one letter!
I have always marvelled at the times achieved. I simply luxuriate In taking my time to complete the challenge.
I am posting because I also live in Sutton Coldfield! It took a few moments to unravel the anagram, but not too long.
Keep up the good work by encouraging others to have a bash at the 15×15.
Thank you all for your expert analyses of the clues.
Jovan.
Edited at 2020-08-28 01:02 pm (UTC)
Thanks for your kind words.
I have been a huge admirer of your encouraging words to newcomers over the years. Your honesty is also very much admired in your analysis of clues and the time it takes you.
The TV transmitter, I believe, is still there as such, but no longer is it operational. It has not been used for several years so my wife tells me. She was born here!
Keep up the sterling work!
Jovan.
SUTTON COLDFIELD we’ve had fairly recently?
Liked SHAWMS and OFFA’s dyke, which is nearby, most spectacularly at World’s End between Wrexham and Llangollen.
BANANA PEEL was lovely, and the NHO answers fairly clued, including SHAWMS, PRESCOTT, BROWN EARTH, TICCA.
Otherwise quite impossibly difficult but some very good clues. My knowledge of film directors is so bad that I thought there was one called Lee Anderson, so couldn’t understand where the shelter came from. Never heard of Prescott and he isn’t in a long list of US historians in Google. But it was nicely clued, and not too hard so long as you take it on trust that he exists.
I think it’s possible that the clue that was rethought and improved – either from “remove file from its case” or from “remove doctor’s case from file”, and the editing didn’t catch up. Either way, my point that, if its an easy puzzle with simple grid-fill the setter has more latitude; if its got difficult grid-fill (and this did) and difficult and clever cluing (and this did) then you can’t be sloppy with wording.
Meantime, the only Ozzie I know of is Ozzie Nelson, from The Adventures of Ozzie and Harriet. With no disrespect, even a conveyance lawyer discussing the intricacies of property law would be better company than O&H reruns.
Excellent crossword overall – unfortunately I entered “Tun” instead if “Ton” so I’m a DNF – I should have remembered Ton = Style from previous crosswords. Somehow I got it into my mind that Nut could mean crossword clue – certainly a tough nut to crack!
My grandfather had an Anderson Shelter in his back garden, so that helped me ( and my Spanish language teacher is called Ines).
Edited at 2020-08-28 03:00 pm (UTC)
I’m reading a book by an American historian (Eric Foner) at the moment but that was of no use to me today.
I suspect the intended Anderson is Michael of Dam Busters fame but I thought of Wes.
I knew of Yellowcoats before I knew they were based on something real.
Edited at 2020-08-28 03:10 pm (UTC)
After 16 minutes I was left with the NW corner, which took almost another 6 minutes. NHO PRESCOTT, but a lovely clue. DNK TICCA, but I always think this sort of thing is best in a “hidden” so no complaints. DNK BROWN EARTH but it was obvious (eventually !)
As observed in my response to Rob Rolfe earlier, I couldn’t parse SUTTON COLDFIELD despite a three year residency 50 years ago -thanks V !
FOI CONCUR
LOI CROWN COURT
COD CREDIT LIMIT (loved TON and OFFA too !)
TIME 21:47
Quite hard but I wasn’t on best form distracted by domestic issues.
Edited at 2020-08-28 01:34 pm (UTC)
1a. Didn’t know the historian, but with the first three checkers, the answer was plain enough and gave the final checker for 4d.
10a. Enough checkers for FIELD early on though I thought that might be the ‘ground’. More checkers made further parsing unnecessary.
11a. Never heard of the answer but the cryptic was clear.
19a. Vaguely recalled word guessed from S___M_
21a. Alphabet sweep to work this out from both checkers.
25a. Got from all checkers in first word – no idea about the director.
28a. From checkers – no idea about the Spanish lady.
4d. Guessed hidden from checkers.
9d. Biffed from first three checkers.
12d. Not sure I’d heard of the WINDOW but having eliminated those letters, rearranged the others.
26d. Vague on this one. Hit and hope!
Thanks v.
Finished eventually with all correct in 72mins, nho ANDERSON SHELTER took a large part of this, finally seeing ‘shelter’ as ‘lee’, then guessing the name from checkers.
Geographically, it’s only a few miles from Walsall, which IS classed as Black Country, but the two towns could hardly be more different.
Found it tough going in parts, kept thinking of the Director Ang Lee. COD 1a, though hadn’t the faintest idea who he was. Thanks
Banana skin is more familiar to me than BANANA PEEL and it took me an age to spot GLIB.
CIAO & REDCOAT were good clues – and my COD is SUTTON COLDFIELD which competes with Solihull (where I was born) for being one of the supposedly more upmarket areas of the West Midlands.
Thanks to the setter and to V for the comprehensive blog.
Edited at 2020-08-28 11:08 pm (UTC)
Edited at 2020-08-28 10:58 pm (UTC)
Don’t think I’ve missed any, unless there’s an OLDFIELD or a TOUT?